Proposal #14: From Elephant to Butterfly.
I propose that CISV international changes its administration from being an elephant to become a butterfly.
To do this the following changes should be implemented:
- IO should have maximum 3 full time employees, for general administration and project management
- All administration work including pool creation, form delivery, invitation acceptation/refusal, address book management, fee management, document management should be handled by an online application to be tailored for CISV with an open technology
- International committees should be reduced to 6: IEC, IJB, ODC, ERC, IMC and IAC ("International Activity Committee"):
- IFC and IRMC should be integrated into ODC as subcommittees as well as as a new QAC ("Quality Assurance Committee") with will conglomerate the actual functions of EDR and ILTC
- All program and activities committee should be integrated as subcommittees into IAC
Nowadays CISV International moves with the same effectivenss of an elephant in the center of Manhattan. CISV is not able to respond effectively to the extremely volatile opportunities offered by the world today.
The high fixed costs and the inflexibility towards new experiences and projects is immobilizing our organization, which does not offer anymore what people need. The reason we exist will cease to support us soon if we don't face structural changes.
The structure we have today is centralized structure which was needed to strengthen the organization in a different time. What we need is few very dynamic project managers which shouldn't be bothered by administration problem. We need avoid duplicate efforts and have an effective decision making procedures.
So how the proposed changes will help CISV to mutate from an elephant to a butterfly?
- Cutting IO fixed costs and getting rid of the administration work which on the budget for 2006 is £ 324.684 on a grand total of £ 700.923 (little less than 50% of expences) and considering that excluding £ 216.808 of insurance expences the percentage goes up 65%)
- Any needed structure for pool creation or administration practices could beeasily added to the open technology choosen
- The competence which now is confined inside a particular committe will be diffused to all activity committees, avoiding the duplicated efforts of developing new solution for known problems. The chair of this committee will moreover have a better overall view of all international educational activities offered by our organization
- Mosaic and ijb will assume a more relevant role within the organization and push innovation and dynamism
- Will we loose international activity specialists? No, they are still there, in subcommittees
- Will we have lower quality international acvitites? Nowadays the real quality control to all activites is enforced by each committee, this will still be enforced from subcommittes. Let's face that ILTC and EDR in the past year has not helped the organization in a relevant way .
- Will we loose our identity? Being dynamic doesn't mean change our nature continuosly but adapt our way to operate to the enviroment around us, as times goes by different approach to reach our goals need to be explored. Dynamism of means is not dynamism of goals.
Teo (Italy)

7 Comments:
In principle I agree with this proposal. However, I think it will still have to take many things into consideration. If ODC would not only do what it does today, but also incorporate IFC, IRMC and QAC then we will have to discuss if that's not a full-time position in the IO (or somewhere else) As a volunteer, it would be almost impossible to coordinate this kind of super-super committee. Also the structure of the AIM would have to be taken into consideration, what would be the role of the board then, what of the EEC, what of the AIM as such?
Just a few cents, I hope we can continue discussing this!
CISV's International Office has become very effective at dealing with new opportunities in recent years. In fact, we already ask our paid staff to do a tremendous amount of work -- and it is increasingly difficult to fill volunteer positions if you have a personal life outside of CISV. Can reducing staff levels and increasing volunteer workloads be a positive thing?
This is, again, an example of the problem with CISV -- instead of dealing with important questions about our mission and vision in an external world, we decide to turn internally and re-do our structure . . . again. CISV's bureacracy comes from ineffective leadership and a lack of vision as to our organization's role, not because of problems with our staff.
I think the idea behind this proposal is what generally is understood as "slim governance" in politics. Reduce the number levels of hirachy, reduce the number of employees, reduce the number of ministers, reduce the amount of tax collected, reduce the number of laws, etc, etc. In real politics, this gives way to a more market-driven economy, but also enables the government to make faster moves. The country of Germany is probably the best example for the "elephant" in Teo's example: A huge beaurocratic country, unable to adapt to a changing world around them, while smaller countries have a much easier time reforming themselves.
In many ways I think CISV should also consider a "slim governance". Most of all, because of the inflated budget. CISV moves ONLY 6000 participants areound the world every year. Let's not waste time, resources and energy on administration, but focus on hosting the programmes themselves.
However, the devil is in the details, as usual:
- An employee at IO costs (I believe) around 30000 GBP/y. Imagine what an international volunteer committee could do with this money? But would they work as consistent as a fulltime IO person?
- Creating the IAC (international activity committee) sounds interesting, but would create another level of administration in CISV. Personally, I doubt that the existing super-committees ERC (eternal relations committee) and ODC (organisational development committee) are pure success stories.
- The best part of the proposal, I believe, is the rationalization part: Let's look into the administratie tasks that are done by IO, and see how they can be reduced through clever IT-solutions. Since no such software exists, the best thing would probably be to hire a real IT-fellow (a programmer) for IO, to develop this tool together with volunteers.
QUOTE
"This is, again, an example of the problem with CISV -- instead of dealing with important questions about our mission and vision in an external world, we decide to turn internally and re-do our structure . . . again. CISV's bureacracy comes from ineffective leadership and a lack of vision as to our organization's role, not because of problems with our staff."
TRANSLATION
Our organization doesn't develop effecive leaders. These people they cannot forseen what is the future of CISV.
COMMENT
I don't agree with this and i would like to be able to know who I'm arguing with.
Teo, I think it's perfectly o.k. to post anonymous comments on the CISV devils website. If you disagree with this persons position, I think you shoud elaborate...
I personally think there is some truth in there that CISV tends to restructure itself over and over again. Maybe it's more the content that should develop and not the fasade or structure.
Then again, looking back at the past 10 years of CISV, I think a lot of changes have developed. CISV friends, IPP, Mosaic. Maybe it's not moving fast enough for some, but then again, we're also an elephant because CISV is spread over so many countries - read: a huge animal with only a small brain :)
Cheers, Nick
What i tried to ague previously is that:
1) I don't agree about the fact that CISV has an "ineffective leadership and a lack of vision as to our organization's role". I believe that most of the people involved at the international level are very good and smart leaders.
2) I don't agree about the fact that "instead of dealing with important questions about our mission and vision in an external world, we decide to turn internally and re-do our structure... again". All of us is much more projected externally, but sometime to give a coherent image towards the outside to have to put in order the inside too.
3) I know is fine to be anonymous to post comment, but when aguing with somebody i would really appreciate to know who is the other party
My argument is not that the people are ineffective, but that they are within an organization that imposes ineffective systems upon them. I apologize that it came across as negative towards the people in the organization.
Something for consideration: there is a difference between administration and bureacracy. We have very effective and (for the number of staff we have) efficient administration -- so maybe it's not the committees and IO that operate like an elephant. I do not think CISV could function without its current level of staffing at IO, but I would be interested to have their opinion on this. Already committees have a very large amount of work to do and maintaining volunteer motivation is always a problem. And whenever we talk about cutting administration costs, these are expenses picked up by other individuals: volunteers, for example, who then have to pay their travel to AIM to do work previously done by staff as well as the many extra hours of administrative work that would be expected of volunteers. It isn't realistic.
Instead, maybe the organization's problem is its bureaucratic Board of Trustees. How many organizations have a board of over 60 people? Does our board structure lend itself to effective day-to-day operations? The responsibilities between the executive and the board are not clear -- and as a result we have a weak executive committee unable to make important strategic decisions based on a coherent strategic plan throughout the year.
This is the root of leadership problems: The leaders we have are stuck in an organizational model that doesn't make sense. Why not elect an executive that has the power to carry out strategic directives over a three-year period? Are we more effective because we have a board of so many people that we very rarely have effective decision-making skills?
Why don't we look at having an organization with effective staff capacities that would then allow our volunteers to do what they love: run programs and recruit new participants.
So I'll admit that some additional work is needed around the organization's structure -- but I think we need to define what the organization needs and how best to serve those needs. Too often we work on making new rules and committees rather than assessing the fundamental aspects of our programing and figuring out how to best deliver these.
I've included my name on this post, although I think having the option of posting anonymously is very important.
Post a Comment
<< Home