Welcome to the think-tank for outside-the-box proposals.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Proposal #43: The one-hundred pound participant.

I propose to simplify the international fee structure to a single fee of 100 pounds per participant per programme.

This fee will replace "international membership fee", "particpation fee" and "host fee" or any other fees paid to IO by the NAs - except the insurance fee.

Rationale

CISVs current fee system may exist for a reason. It may be the result of a a historic development. It may take the individual nature of different porgrammes into account. It may favour some programmes over others (deliberately or not). But one thing is sure: It is terribly complicated: What is the difference between a membership fee an a host fee? Why do Seminar camps have an extra staff travel fee?

Therefore I suggest to radically simplify the fee system to one single fee that an NA pays per participant per programme. At that shall be 100 GBP. With 5700 participants anticipated for 2008 it will easily cover the anticipated costs for all committees, AIM and IO excluding insurance, roughly 500.000 GBP.

I would like to leave it to the NAs to adapt this fee to their needs: You want to raise funds for hosting camps? Charge 200 GBP instead! You think 100 GBP is to expensive for YM compared to village? Charge villagers 150 GBP and YM 50, as long as IO gets the 100 on average.

Respectfully submitted, Nick (GER)

Monday, September 17, 2007

Proposal #42: Commitees and NGOs

I propose that each committee and taskforce will be in charge of networking with NGO of their area of competence and this will be included in their terms of reference. In particular in O-15 will be included as IJB responsibility the networking with National & Regional Youth Councils.

Rationale

NGO team of ERC did an amazing job pushing the organization to realize how important is to reach out cooperating with other NGO. Now from the PUSH approach we have to move to a PULL approach in which every committee is resposable of its own NGO relation, established in the framework designed by ERC.
This is because each committee has such specific issues to deal with:
  • IJB is the perfect body of the organization to enstablish relation with Youth Councils
  • IPP to enstablish relation with working camps NGO
  • IVC to enstablish relation with NGO working with kids
  • IRMC to enstablish relation with NGO working on risk
Is un-realistic and un-fair to let only ERC to deal with all these relations.

Respectfully submitted, Teo (ITA)

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Proposal #41: Restructure CISV international

I propose that an effort is made to find a big international consulting company that will advise CISV to completely re-arrange the work done by CISV international with the goal of reducing cost to 50%.

Rationale

I strongly believe that for the fact that we are sending only 7000 people to camps every year, I believe our international budget is extraordinary. The biggest numbers in our budget are insurance, IO and AIM. Being an optimist, I think with some clever re-arranging of our work, these costs could be reduced by 50%. Some examples of how this could be achieved are:
  • Move IO to a location where rents and labour costs are less expensive
  • Reduce IO full time staff to 2-3 to cover administration and install computer software to run the rest
  • Create working space at IO for 5-6 interns who will work for a small salary for 3-12 months on specific projects
  • Host AIM only every two years
  • Select AIM locations that will save money on both ends (travel and accomodation)
  • Re-arrange the work between IO and volunteers in a more clever way.
Reducing international cost will have a number of enormous benefits:
  • Participation fees could be reduced making CISV more inclusive
  • A suprplus could be used to speed up filling our self-insurance fund
  • Chapters and NAs will have more cash to run activities
Since this is such a complicated and huge effort, I would suggest that we try to find an international consulting company (McKinsey, BCG) that would be willing to a study of this kind for free. A search for Ex-CISVers working in such a company may help finding such a company.

Respectfully submitted, Nick (GER)